It's hard to match up a fender unless you blend it with the rest of the car, but that should cost no more then $500 dollars for an excellent job. If all your looking for is to have the fender painted to match up as close as possible then it should only run around $100. Hell...I paint entire cars for only $700 and thats with base/clear and buffing!! I can paint your fender in about a hour and have you off on your way. If your close to Petersburg let me know and i could help you out.