Well here is why i was leaning more towards the TL.

1. I think it would look really good lowered with the right wheels. (so would the bmw but ill get to that)

2. Gas mileage and maintenance is going to be cheaper with the TL

3.I think bmw is a better car but i think for my first purchase the TL would be smarter b/c it is cheaper and i could always trade that in on what i really want......an M3...which i think if i bought the bmw i would just be mad it wasn't an M3 or the new 335.

4. The TL is a six speed...at least i think they all are.

5. TLs interiors is one of the best for the money if you ask me.