Never eaten at Martha's Vineyard have you? If having "barn" in the name discourages you, I suspect you would never eat at a place called "Lure" or a plethora of restaurants in New York City. Come on now..

My point.. I was thoroughly impressed with the restaurant. Is it the best by far? No. I've yet to visit a Melting Pot where I left not wanting more unfortunately. Each restaurant will have it's ups and downs -- it all breaks down to what you're after specifically (ie. quantity, quality, class, etc.)