Hamiltons Collision in Salem did an excellent job painting a car for me in the past. Reasonable price too. Cuz has done great work too when I've had an insurance claim. I let Hannabass and Rowe repaint a bumper on my 06 si since it was the geico shop (not my insurance) and I could pick up a rental on spot. I need to take it back again since my HFP front lip is coming loose and you can see the double sided tape sticking out in spots.

As far as tires I've had good and bad experiences with White Tire Salem, Firestone on 419 and Merchants in Salem. Quality Tire on Williamson gave me a hell of a deal on new tires earlier this year but that guy has moved to Firestone at Crossroads. I think tire shops are just hit and miss because of the turnover and people that just dont give a shit.