This whole discussion is even more ridiculous than the Mustang vs Camaro debate.

You will NOT find an unbiased opinion on an internet forum like this.

I personally would choose an STi over an Evo. I'll gladly give up a few hp for the comfort of knowing the car will start up and drive every day. Why Mitsu decided to build such a great motor, and then back it with a weak transmission is beyond me. In my opinion, the base Evo 9 with the 5 speed is the best Evo they've ever built. It's no STi transmission, but it's not made from balsa like their other trannies.